Dwight Merideth at PLA had a well-argued post the other day about the failure of the Bush White House to "change the tone in Washington." He and I both agree that Bush has failed to do so, or even to give it much of a try. But, to be fair, it's isn't just Bush's fault. The problem seems to be deep in the DNA of his party.
Jeff Cooper had a post a few days ago which clearly hit a nerve; I've seen it quoted by several left leaning bloggers. In brief, Jeff said,
I find myself reading the warblogs less and less. It's not simply because they support the president's posture toward Iraq, a subject about which I have serious misgivings. It's that so many of them deny any legitimacy whatsoever to those who hold positions different from their own.
He cited
a post from Bill Quick
The left is clueless, suicidal, morally bankrupt, and ethically a contradiction, concerned only with power for the sake of power and, yes, in their lust for a phony "internationalism," deeply and profoundly unpatriotic. They hate the spirit of the Constitution, wish to pick and choose among those few parts of it they like, loathe America, are ashamed to be American (despite all their lies about "loving America, they don't really love this country - they love only their desperate, ugly wish for an America structured to the socialist, statist horror they truly desire), and would destroy the America of the Founders and the Constitution in a moment if they could wave a magic red wand and do so.
The comments are down on this particular Bill Quick post, which is a shame. There was a real Alleluia chorus underneath. Someone said that they wish they had the money to print it as a full-page ad in newspapers across the country. Someone else suggested that Bill should work for the Republican Party. I didn't see anyone saying that Bill had gone too far.
So what, right? It's just a blogger, just a comment board. It's not exactly news that there are people out there who loathe "the left". There are people who think that we're actually malevolent trolls who want to destroy the United States. These are probably some of the same people
who wrote to Glenn Reynolds in anger because he linked to a commercial for the House Democratic Caucus.
Well, but it's not just bloggers.
At Uggabugga, there's a list of some of the things that major right-wing pundits have said about Al Gore last week. There's the persistent story that
Bob Somerby has been attacking all week, in which Brit Hume edited Gore's quotes to make it look as if Gore had flip-flopped. In my opinion, Hume forfeited any pretense of journalistic credibility by editing Gore's truthful statement into a lie, but the new story of "Gore's flip-flop" is entering the common wisdom.
Ah, but that's just Al Gore, right? You can't expect right-wing pundits to tell the truth about Al Gore.
But it's not just right-wing pundits, either. It goes up to the very top of the Republican party.
Pandagon has a swell collection of quotes from just one week. For example:
"[T]he Senate is more interested in special interests in Washington and not interested in the security of the American people."*
-George W. Bush
"I always see two Jewish communities in America. One of deep intellect and one of shallow, superficial intellect...Conservatives have a deeper intellect and tend to have 'occupations of the brain' in fields like engineering, science and economics. Liberals, on the other hand, tend to flock to 'occupations of the heart."
-Dick Armey
"You've never seen a campaign where anyone will attack [Sen. Tom Harkin] like we're going to attack him[.]"
-Greg Ganske
And there's
this case:
In a heated C-SPAN debate with his colleague, Representative Bob Filner, Wilson said, "This hatred of America by some people is just outrageous. And you need to get over that." Filner asked, "Hatred of America? ... Are you accusing me?," to which Wilson replied, "Yes!" According to The Washington Post, Wilson proceeded to accuse Filner of "hatred of America" four more times and being "viscerally anti-American" once.
If I read a quote like Dick Armey's on a right-wing blog, I wouldn't think much of it. It's just a blog; people have the right to be idiots. But this guy is the
House Majority Leader. He is one of the most powerful people in the world. And if I'm reading him correctly, he's capable of dismissing a position, not because it's right or wrong, but
because it's the left-wing position. For people like him, right is right, and left is left, and that's all ye need to know. (Am I going beyond his original statement? Maybe. But as a Texas Democrat, do I have a prayer of expecting him to fairly consider the issues important to me? Not bloody likely.)
Can you imagine Tom Daschle or Dick Gephardt insulting conservatives- all conservatives- in that way? Call me a partisan hack, but I can't. Can you imagine a Democratic Congressman accusing a Republican colleague of hating America, and then refusing to apologize? I can't.
I treasure my favorite conservative bloggers; I consider them invaluable to achieving a nuanced understanding of politics. But it bothers me tremendously to see the Coulterization of so much of the right wing, from the top to the bottom. How do you argue with people like this?
* Incidentally, I've been cautioned about taking stuff from
Media Whores Online, so consider yourself warned. But this got my attention.
American People Care More About Special Interests Than Own Security
Newsweek Poll conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates.
Latest: Sept. 26-27, 2002.
N=1,011 adults nationwide. MoE ± 3 (total sample).
"In creating a new Department of Homeland Security, the Bush Administration wants to remove union status from approximately 170,000 workers, in order to have greater authority to hire, fire and deploy workers. Do you approve of this proposal to remove the union status of current workers in a new Homeland Security Department, OR do you think these workers should keep their union status?"
Remove union status 23%
They should keep union status 65%
Don't know 12%
To quote
Atrios, "Why does America hate America so much?"
UPDATE:
Rob Lyman says I'm a partisan hack. Fair enough.